Victory Spirit Essay Example for Free

Victory Spirit EssayWilliam Safire and James Wood are two contrastive people, with assorted ideas, polar views, exclusively do have similar committal to writing styles. In William Safires A Spirit Reborn he duologue about(predicate) the Gettysburg Address in comparison to 9/11 and he in any case analyzes the Gettysburg Address in more depth and has a specific purpose for writing his article. On the other hand in James Woods Victory Speech he talks about how President Obama flowed through different things, Wood excessively analyzes certain details of Obamas mother tongue, and offers some critique. Now, as then, a populational spirit rose from the ashes of destruction (Safire 41).The Gettysburg Address was given aft(prenominal) a horrible incident, with very tragic losses. By going through these destructive events, our nation becomes stronger, and more bonded in concert. After 9/11, the Gettysburg Address was reborn to take in us remembrance, togetherness and encourag ement through tough times. In his essay, Safire states that 9/11 was the worst bloodbath on our territory since Antietam Creek (41). By bringing fanny past events such as the battle of Antietam, Safire probably strikes a lot of strong emotion from his readers by using it in comparison to 9/11.To reprocess a speech such as the Gettysburg Address at a time such as after 9/11 was unlikely to be thought of, since they were two different events, 138 years apart. In Safires article in the New York Times, he analyzes the Gettysburg Address in more detail. He talks about how you entrust hear the word dedicate five times (Safire 42), and what each wholeness of them stand for. For example, he says the first two refer to the nations dedication to two ideals mentioned in the Declaration of Independence Liberty that all men are created equal (Safire 42).The third is pointed towards a certain clemency of the location of the battle of Gettysburg, and the fourth and fifth dedications are direc ted back to the thoughts of liberty and that all men are created equal, for which the deceased men of the battle fought for. Safire also notices that the speech is grounded it conception, birth, death, and rebirth (42). He mentions some specific quotes such as The nation was conceived in liberty delivered into life by our fathers (Safire 42). He also brings up death and re-birth by pulling more quotes from Lincolns memorable speech.Safire does not want us to listen to only Lincolns illustrious words and comforting cadences (43). Instead he wants us to remember the message Lincoln was giving to us, he wants us to appreciate the deceased and the missing, and wants to remind us that this generations response to the deaths of thousands of our people leads to a new birth of freedom (Safire 43). First he moved through the people Then he moved through the country then he moved through time (Wood 611). The purpose Wood says for Obama doing this was to bind those wounds by binding us toget her (611).By bringing people from different ages, orientation and gender, from different states and cities, Obama hopes to bring our nation back together as one nation. He also mentions how Ann Nixon Cooper, who is one hundred and six years old, had voted using just a finger, to show how the times have changed. Wood analyzes some details of Obamas speech, such as how Yes we can changed to Yes we did and Yes we may. Noticing the impact those few words had on the crowd by saying it was extraordinarily moving in its sobriety (Wood 611).Wood also mentions how he added it to past tense, using a note of being uncertain. He also draws attention to Obamas use of the word agreement, after Obama says I promise you we as people will get there in reference to a hard road to get to change. Wood says the word promise is apply in acknowledgement to Martin Luther Kings speech from Memphis, King says and Ive seen the Promised Land, I may not get there with you but Obama knows he will indeed get w here we are going. In the beginning of Woods Victory Speech he talks about how last Tuesday night was a very good night for the English language (610).Since James Wood is a critic, it is only fitting that he give some feed-back on urge Obamas speech. He says that many of us would have watched in tears as President-elect Obama had just thanked his campaign staff and shuffled off to bed (Wood 610). Wood says that his speech was filled with such history and emotion, that if he just grumbled thanks, American would not be satisfied. In the end both Safire and Wood had analyzed two different speeches in depth, but Safire had a specific purpose for doing so, to bring emotion, while Wood critiqued. There were a lot of differences, but some similarities, not many, but some.